While I was thinking about security I decided to double check that I’m practicing what I preach.
When building a Rails app I don’t want to roll my own security (too easy to miss things) but I want something that’s simpler and lighter weight than Devise. There are lots of good options in this space but I usually reach for Clearance… I respect the Thoughtbot team’s approach to development, they actively maintain Clearance for use in their own projects and they were responsive when I flagged an issue using Clearance with the upcoming Rails 6 release.
Anyway, I kind of knew that Clearance used BCrypt and salting, but when I looked in my database schema I couldn’t find a column for storing the random salt. After doing a little digging, I discovered that bcrypt-ruby, quite cleverly, securely generates the salt for you and then appends it to the end of the now salted and hashed password. All you need to do is store the result in a single field.
Not only does this prevent well-meaning but clueless developers (i.e. me) from doing silly things with the salt (in a mis-guided attempt at “making it more secure”), but it also simplifies the interface of the library.
On a related note,
bcrypt-ruby cleverly overrides the
== method to let you compare a plaintext password (e.g. that someone just provided at log in) with the stored hash/salt combo to see if it’s a match. Jesus Castello has written a helpful article that just happens to explain this exact mechanism.
All in all, it’s an excellent example of making it easy for the user (in this case application developers) to do the right thing.